[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [syndication] Re: [RSS-DEV] How should a feed tell people it's gone?




Jim Winstead wrote:

What's wrong with HTTP 404?

Nothing, if the feed reader application notifies the person using it.
But most readers don't ever tell the user about the error.
amen to this. i've been returning a 404 on a couple of feeds for months,
and those feeds are still getting more than 600 requests a day. (mostly
from radio userland clients.) one of them occassionally pops up as one
of the top 100 subscribed feeds at http://radio.weblogs.com/.
yes!! Recent Radio does this (stops getting a feed if it failed for
48 hours).

The most popular user agent on NewsIsFree is gnome-vfs. Part of
gnome obviously, not sure what it's used for. It does not report
errors to the user and just gets the feeds over and over again.
I blocked that user agent altogether. Have done so for several
months. In december, I got 1.5 million hits from software with
that agent alone. All for nothing. Crazy.


Mike

--
Mike Krus                                       mkrus@newsisfree.com
http://www.newsisfree.com/blog/                        ICQ: 30900412