Mark Nottingham

Sam wants namespaces

Tuesday, 22 April 2003

Web Feeds

Sam proposes some changes to RSS 2.0 regarding namespaces. My first question was, “why?” but upon reading his next post, I get it.

The Big Problem with namespaces the first time around was that it broke some software, which Dave is very sensitive to. Fair enough.

So, there are a few ways to go about this;

1) change it in the Internet-Draft - but that wouldn’t be RSS2.0, it’d be something else, and I’m quite loath to introduce Yet Another Syndication Format.

2) do RSS 2.1 - ditto.

3) Dave adds a namespace to RSS2.0 - don’t think this will happen, but we can always ask!

4) define an RSS2.0 namespace that ONLY gets used when it’s embedded.

I think the last one is the right approach - if Dave is amenable. How about it, Dave? Sam?